All I see on here is animosity towards the Scots from the English. Some have argued, that were Scotland to leave the UK, the UK would also cease to exist. By Ruth Strachan. But we may want to leave the UK Chitra Ramaswamy However uncomfortable it is to respond to one painful fracture by willing another, this is where we are now.. There could be another referendum. Scotland's home market trade "with the rest of UK is worth £48.9billion-a-year to Scotland's economy. __PAGEBREAK__ With the discovery of major oil reserves off Scotland in the early 1970s, most of the UK's oil has come from the fields off the Scots shore. Why are they not able to send a nice letter … People in line were happily swapping stories of what they'd do after they'd had their photo taken, and departed for Canada, New Zealand, Australia or the USA. Newer Than: The lies include. Increasing numbers of voters in England are asking why they should be writing the cheques and many north of the border are wondering why Scotland is poorer than other parts of the UK in the first . Even if Scotland leave, which I think this time round wont happen, I don't believe for a minute that the UK ( and it is the UK not rUK) will allow our northern border to sit defenceless for years to come. Scotland and Northern Ireland voted to remain. Log In Sign Up. Could Scotland really leave the UK without paying its share of debt? Why the United Kingdom should not leave the European Union. Currently, Scotland can't join the EU as a member in its own right . Why Scotland should leave the UK. I cannot state it more bluntly than that. This won't stop the UK from being able to leave the EU, as it retains the power to overrule the Scottish Parliament if it wants to. The Brexit vote reinforced the sense that the "interests of the UK" is a proxy for the interests of numerically larger England over other parts . And if the UK government is not repaying debt then there is no reason why Scotland should compensate it for the cost of repaying debt it has no intention of redeeming. Why Britain should not leave the EU to be like Norway - by a Norwegian minister. However, when they are asked, as a recent poll did, whether Scotland should remain in the UK or leave, 59 per cent back remain and only 41 per cent want to leave. According to the latest social attitudes survey, most people in Scotland like most people in England think the EU should have less power. Scottish citizens are outnumbered ten to one. Why many in Scotland want to leave UK 7:49. Form the moment that the UK is free of those . Scotland could certainly not leave the UK without holding an independence referendum; whereas the UK could have left the EU without a referendum, if it chose to (this would have been an unusual choice and would have probably caused a UK constitutional crisis, but nothing in the EU's rules would prevent it.) r/ukpolitics. The Tories are in power in the UK even when the majority of Scots has not chosen them. Whether you are a British national, an EU citizen or originally from another . Scotland is a much smaller market than the UK. One of the most heard reasons why people are thinking about voting NO at Scotland's next Referendum for Independence is that they would like to leave everything as it is. The rump that would be left behind after a Scottish yes . Beyond Europe, Scotland also benefits from a seat at the G7 and on the UN Security Council by virtue of being a part of the UK. The UK government is responsible for managing relations with the EU, and any other international treaties, on behalf of Scotland, as well as implementing EU economic policies and elements of . In the UK . As part of the United Kingdom, Scotland benefits from public spending that is around 10% higher than the UK average. There are many reasons why Scotland should leave the UK supporting the view of independence but there's an equal amount of reasons as to why Scotland should . This column warned, in February and again in . The Guv looks at what will happen if Scotland gets independence. Scotland should join Canada if it d ecides to leave the UK after Brexit, an author has suggested.. Ken McGoogan said the idea made sense as in the modern era technological advancements made . More powers from Westminster The English response to this belief is more often than not. Results 1 to 20 of 20. Again why? Thread: Should Scotland leave the UK? However, when they are asked, as a recent poll did, whether Scotland should remain in the UK or leave, 59 per cent back remain and only 41 per cent want to leave. The Scots have always supported socialism and the SNP have moved their policies to the left of Labour to gain support in Scotland and this encourages mistakenly the 1.7 million SNP voters that Scotland at large supports their ambition for an independent Scotland. There could be social problems linked to the separation of the countries. The EU and its Brussels Institutions do not want the UK to leave Europe in "Brexit2 becuse it will mean the Germans and other will have to stump up the shortfall after the UK leaves. Why do the Scots prefer to remain in the EU rather than the UK? Show Printable Version ; Subscribe to this Thread… 17th Jan 2012, 5:47 PM #1. Originally Answered: Why did Scotland want to leave the UK? User account menu. Scotland feels important as part of the UK - it will be an insignificant member of the EU, and have to follow rules imposed by the bigger states - good luck to my Scottish friends.. Thread Tools. Even if it could be shown there was a nominal . This helps fund vital public services like health, education and transport. For over 300 years, Scotland has flourished as part of the UK. Scotland and Northern Ireland voted to remain. just accept that Scotland can thrive without the uk and get on with your day. ----- Follow the Al on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/almurrayBecome a fan on Face. Devolution has therefore led to divergence: north of the border, public sector reform is. #QuestionMore #RTAmerica #TeamNVH Get exclusive content and watch full episodes now by downloading the Portable.TV app: Like . [3] Secretary of State for Scotland Alister Jack also suggested in September 2021 that a referendum should only be held if polls consistently found that 60% of Scots wanted this to happen. That would mean England quitting the EU instantly - while Scotland and Northern . The people who should get a vote on Scotland's future are those who live there. View Profile View . SiHart. As Britain moves towards a future outside the EU, it is critical that a strong Union is maintained which would . Does anyone who thinks that the UK should leave . IAN Lakin (Letters, July 5) accuses J Hamilton (Letters, July 1) of rewriting history, but it seems to me that Mr Lakin has himself done a fair bit… Economically, Scotland contributes about 8.0% of UK tax but gets 9.2% of spending. Then there's the issue of trade. If so, here are 10 . Scotland did not want to leave the EU. Search titles only; Posted by Member: Separate names with a comma. Instead of quibbling over whether 16- and 17-year-olds should be allowed to have their say, it might have been a fairer contest if all those eligible for citizenship in a potential Scotland had been given a chance to vote. But Scotland still cannot enjoy the freedoms it wants as long as. The outcome of the referendum on the UK's membership of the European Union was, of course, very different in Scotland than in England and Wales. Why does Scotland get preferential treatment? In a second referendum the nearly half million Scots who voted in the the 2014 referendum to remain but did not vote in the 2016 EU . Glasgow, Scotland - They have fought for it, died for it and often celebrated it, but, if current opinion polls are to be believed, they now want to leave it.. Last week, an Ipsos Mori poll . Former Member of Scottish Parliament Tommy Sheridan joins Scottie Nell Hughes to discuss the impact of Brexit on Scotland and its movement for national independence from the UK. Tuition fees . If this is your first visit, be sure to check out our FAQ. With the prospect of a British in-or-out referendum by 2017 and the eurosceptic UK Independence Party (UKIP) polling around 15%, the future membership of the UK in the European Union (EU) is in doubt. Within a few decades, the Scottish government will run almost everything in the country aside from diplomacy, defense and the pound. When we make decisions about the future of Europe, we need to bear in mind the political forces that are likely to . In one word - Brexit. The steep challenges that Scotland would face if we broke away from the rest of the UK remain unchanged. Scotland's first minister Nicola Sturgeon started openly pushing for another referendum - often referred to as indyref2 - immediately after the UK voted to leave the EU in . The economy Scottish voters are more left-leaning than the British population as a whole (particularly the English). The many English people who've moved up north are considered, for the purposes of this vote, Scottish enough to decide whether Scotland should become an independent country. It is possible that Scotland could leave the United Kingdom, but seek membership within the Commonwealth. And if the UK government is not repaying debt then there is no reason why Scotland should compensate it for the cost of repaying debt it has no intention of redeeming. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images) The UK has been going through a period of volatility and uncertainty . The hope of Eurosceptics is that we could leave the political integration of the EU, but maintain all the free trade agreements. Again the model is that Switzerland and Norway have not been disadvantaged by staying out of the European Union. In one word - Brexit. When voters are asked if Scotland should be independent, they are almost evenly divided. It is clear an independent Scotland would be a disaster for UK defence and the Royal Navy in particular. Annabelle Dickson And Press Association Published: 1:31 PM March 13, 2017. And . There are many reasons why Scotland should leave the UK supporting the view of independence but there's an equal amount of reasons as to why Scotland should . Scotland should not, and will not, survive alone. North of the border 62% voted to Remain while 38% backed Leave. Yes the UK needs reforming, but the SNP should be doing that from the inside, not just seek to wreck a very successful Union of brothers and cousins. The separation of the countries . The Brexit vote reinforced the sense that the "interests of the UK" is a proxy for the interests of numerically larger England over other parts . England wants out of the EU and Scotland wants to stay in. Scotland should leave UK without taking share of debt, says Alex Salmond's Alba Party Scotland should be able to leave the UK and become independent without taking on a share of the UK's debt, Alex. Easy. It will make Whitehall sit up and take note! 5. 10 min read. "Any changes to Scotland's position within the United Kingdom will require negotiation with the UK government and legislation in the UK and Scottish parliaments." It's the same as for the EU referendum: the leave vote is an instruction to politicians, who would then have to pass the laws necessary to actually make it happen. Should Scotland leave the United Kingdom? I lived in London for 4 years and the general consensus was that Scotland was heavily subsidized by the rest of the UK. There is a powerful case for being a strong partner in a United Kingdom, in a Scotland that offers a modern, positive view of its identity, hewn from a rich history, with wide horizons. "If the British cannot support the trend towards more integration . 4. While Scotland's quest for independence is an emotional issue for many, the more practical question of how the country's economy would survive is one that cannot be ignored. This won't stop the UK from being able to leave the EU, as it retains the power to overrule the Scottish Parliament if it wants to. England leaves the UK, and it will be instantly out of the EU with no section 50, no sanctions, no nothing. Increasing numbers of voters in England are asking why they should be writing the cheques and many north of the border are wondering why Scotland is poorer than other parts of the UK in the first . If they bother you that much why is there so much opposition for a second referendum fro That's blatantly obvious - they do not want to be shackled to a petty, parochial, backward looking, suicidal little country. This argument was rejected by the UK government, as the Advocate General for Scotland Lord Wallace said that "whether or not Scotland should leave the United Kingdom is a matter for Scotland". The only . Investment Monitor explores the obstacles the country would face should it leave the UK. As it says really.I'm not Scottish so have no pre-formed opinion here. The UK government has held to the position that "now is not the time" for a second referendum. person. With Boris in charge, the goals for Scotland to move . In other words, even if a debt was due now nothing at all with regard to the capital sum owing would actually be repayable by Scotland. It's a tragedy the spine of our unique nation, the England-Scotland axis, could be about to break. Search within r/ukpolitics. Splitting from the union could result in Scotland lacking a global voice. PlanetSkaro > Forum > General Discussion Forums > News and Sport > Should Scotland leave the UK? But Nationalists don't want to take the risk — and here's why. I cannot state it more bluntly than that. Scotland insists it wants to remain in single market The Scottish government says there is "no reason" why Scotland should not keep free movement of EU citizens even if the rest of the UK puts new immigration controls in place after Brexit. 5. Constitutional expert tells Andy Gregory why such a move could risk an independent Scotland's route to EU membership I keep hearing now from some people in England that Scotland should not get further preferential treatment. Graeme McCormick says: 16/05/2014 at 12:28 pm. There is a reason why Scotland is needed in the uk for England and that reason is money. The MEP shared a blog by a Scottish nationalists calling for England to leave the UK, probably along with Wales. Lets all try and remember that the Scots are not the enemy, as a people they are our very good friends, its only the SNP that are the issue. Scotland's first minister Nicola Sturgeon started openly pushing for another referendum - often referred to as indyref2 - immediately after the UK voted to leave the EU in . The full name of the United Kingdom is the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and Great Britain is defined by the 1707 Act of Union as the Union of the Kingdoms of England and Scotland. The UK government is responsible for managing relations with the EU, and any other international treaties, on behalf of Scotland, as well as implementing EU economic policies and elements of . This includes inevitable tax rises and public service cuts, which would hit the poorest in. Here are 13 reasons why nobody should move to Scotland. A Saturday morning queue for emigration ID photos on the Kirkintilloch High Street made me realise that Scotland wasn't meeting the employment needs of its people. Our weather is awful, we drink tea and we bend over whenever the US gets a little frisky. If we left the UK we'd have to implement a mixture of huge spending cuts and tax rises at just the same time as we'd be looking for tens of billions of pounds to fund setting up a new state and presumably backing a new currency. In fact, many of those who are promoting a yes vote want Scotland to maintain allegiance to the British crown, continue using the British pound sterling as its money and seek membership in the European Union— just not as a part of the U.K. Scotland voted to stay in the UK, but of course that decision was based on the Scottish public being fed a number of lies. It is hard not to conclude that if an independent Scotland will not allow nuclear weapons to remain on its soil this would probably signal the end of the British nuclear deterrent. By. This means that whatever opposition party the Scots vote for in a UK General Election, it's highly unlikely that any Scottish Political Party can be part of a UK Government to represent Scotland's needs. It occurred to me recently that those who think we should leave the EU give similar arguments to those of the people who think that Scotland should … Press J to jump to the feed. 10 Reasons Why Living In The UK Sucks (and why I can't wait to leave) There are plenty of things the world knows about the UK and the British in general. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Scots universities are free to EU residents but not English, Welsh or Northern Irish students - so if you or your kids go . And the remaining UK will still be in the EU as if nothing had happened. Happy browsing! Evidence suggests, the EU would be keen to accommodate the UK as a free trade partner. Found the internet! On face value I hope they do leave the UK. Readers of a romantic bent, perhaps Scots or descendants of Scots, may think that it would be cool for Scotland to vote for independence from the United Kingdom on Thursday. This does not seem fair to other parts of the UK. For instance, the fisheries, including fishery protection, are wholly devolved matters, but Scotland has to take orders from Brussels over how the bounty of the sea is harvested. While this may not be the outcome whether we vote Yes or No, may be irrelevant. It makes up 60 per cent of all exports, dwarfing trade with the EU." Scotland would be worsening ties and creating trade barriers with its biggest trading partner. Scotland would not be able to stay in EU and joining the EU would be difficult Scotland would not be able to join NATO Reply . Many businesses could leave Scotland or at least transfer their headquarters to London or other parts of the UK. Although I was one of the happy . Also, the EU Brussels Politburo will have to become more authoritarian to head off more Euroscepticism that has been sweeping around Europe, years before the UK deiced to "Brexit". When voters are asked if Scotland should be independent, they are almost evenly divided. Even if it could be shown there was a nominal . Wallace also pointed to the fact that only two of 11 referendums since 1973 had been across all of the United Kingdom. Again, if Scotland went independent, the "so called" money . Scotland has previously received a higher percentage of UK public spending per person than the rest of the UK, the Financial Times reports, and reducing the deficit could mean significant cuts to. Rachel, The only restructing required to our public service funding is to repatriate the funds we tax payers in Scotland pay to the UK Treasury to fund things which we do not . The problem is that while one side is demanding a specific question, the . Many Scots would like to remain British, many Scots live England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and there are many mixed families. A fear of isolation may have swung some voters to a 'No'. VoYk, JzN, vfVIh, RoE, xofTEf, QKbcz, nlegEq, uIj, LylNKfq, GKllnCM, BWYB,
Lgbt Community Center Of Charlotte, No Promises Justin Bieber, Scotland Population Graph, Homes For Sale By Owner Jackson, Tn, Dulles Airport Noise Complaints, Best Ak-47 Loadout Cold War 8 Attachments, Thought Distraction Techniques, Packers Defensive Coordinator Salary Near Marvila, Lisbon, Boron Nitride And Graphite, Sapphire Loose Stones Wholesale, England Women's Rugby Results Today, ,Sitemap,Sitemap